Italian Beef Sandwich Recipe

I have to laugh when I think about how this recipe came into my life. It all started with my brother-in-law Tony, who’s from Chicago and never stops talking about how nobody outside of his hometown can make a “real” Italian beef sandwich. Every family gathering, he’d go on and on about this place or that place back home, and how we poor souls in our little town would never understand true Italian beef.

Well, you know how that kind of talk sits with a woman who’s been cooking for her family for twenty years! Last summer, during our annual Fourth of July barbecue, Tony was at it again with his Chicago food stories when I finally said, “That’s it. I’m going to figure out how to make these famous sandwiches of yours.”

I spent the next week researching everything I could find about Italian beef. Turns out, it’s all about slow-cooking a big roast until it falls apart, then slicing it thin and piling it high on crusty rolls with that flavorful jus. The secret, I learned, was in the seasoning blend and letting that beef cook low and slow until it’s so tender you can practically cut it with a fork.

My first attempt was pretty good, but I knew I could do better. I played around with the spice mix, adding more oregano here, a little extra garlic there, until I got that perfect balance of Italian herbs that makes your kitchen smell like heaven. Then came the technique of getting the beef sliced just right – thin enough to be tender but thick enough to have some substance.

The real test came at our next family dinner when I served up my version to Tony. I’ll never forget watching him take that first big bite, juice dripping down his chin, and then just going quiet. After what felt like forever, he looked at me and said, “Okay, this is actually really good. Maybe even Chicago good.”

What Is an Italian Beef Sandwich?

An Italian beef sandwich is thinly sliced, slow-cooked beef piled onto a soft hoagie roll with its flavorful juices, then topped with tangy peppers and giardiniera. I first learned about it from my brother-in-law Tony, who swore no one outside Chicago could ever make it right. Determined to prove him wrong, I started experimenting in my kitchen with a big roast, Italian spices, and a slow cooker. The magic happens as the beef cooks low and slow until it’s tender enough to fall apart. When you build the sandwich, every bite is juicy, messy, and packed with rich flavor.

Ingredients You Need for Italian Beef Sandwiche

PIN IT

• Chuck roast or round roast (3 to 4 pounds) – slow-cooks until tender and easy to shred

• Kosher salt – seasons the beef from the start

• Beef broth – keeps the meat moist and creates the rich jus

• Pepperoncini pepper slices plus juice – add a bright, tangy kick

• Giardiniera (mild or spicy, drained) – brings texture and zesty flavor

• Provolone cheese slices – melt over the hot beef for a creamy layer

• Hoagie buns – hold the juicy beef and toppings

• Italian seasoning, granulated sugar, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, black pepper, dried thyme – the seasoning blend that gives the beef its signature taste

PIN IT

Kitchen Equipment Needed

• Large skillet or Dutch oven – for searing the beef and building flavor before slow cooking

• Slow cooker or crockpot – cooks the beef low and slow until it shreds easily

• Cutting board – gives you space to prep the meat and measure spices

• Sharp chef’s knife – makes trimming and slicing the beef simple

• Measuring cups and spoons – keep the seasonings and liquids accurate

• Small mixing bowl – to stir together the seasoning blend

• Wooden spoon or spatula – for scraping up browned bits and stirring ingredients

• Tongs – help turn and transfer the roast safely

• Baking sheet – to toast the hoagie rolls before serving

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make the beef in a slow cooker or Instant Pot?

Yes. Both methods work beautifully. Cooking the beef slowly lets it become tender and soak up all the rich juices.

What kind of bread should I use?

A sturdy Italian roll or hoagie bun works best. Look for bread that can hold up to the juicy beef without getting soggy too fast.

Can I make the beef ahead of time?

Absolutely. Cook the beef a day before, store it in its juices in the fridge, and reheat gently before assembling sandwiches.

How do I make the sandwich less spicy or more spicy?

You can control the heat by adjusting the amount of giardiniera or pepperoncini. Add more for extra kick or go light for a milder taste.

How should I store leftovers?

Keep the beef and its juices in a covered container in the fridge for up to 4 days. Reheat slowly on the stove so it stays tender.

Don’t Miss More Recipes