Honey Old Bay Sauce Recipe

Last summer, I was hosting a backyard barbecue and desperately trying to come up with something different to serve with our usual grilled shrimp. I’d already made cocktail sauce, and frankly, I was getting bored with the same old condiments. That’s when I spotted two things sitting next to each other on my counter: a bottle of honey and my trusty container of Old Bay seasoning.

Now, I know what you’re thinking – honey and Old Bay sounds like a weird combination. Trust me, I thought the same thing. But I was running out of time before guests arrived, and sometimes desperation leads to the best discoveries.

I started with just a small batch, whisking honey with a little mayo for creaminess, then adding Old Bay one teaspoon at a time. My husband walked into the kitchen, took one look at what I was doing, and said, “That’s either going to be amazing or completely terrible.”

When I gave him a taste on a spoon, his eyebrows shot up. “Oh wow,” he said, immediately reaching for another taste. “That’s actually incredible. It’s sweet, but spicy, but also… I can’t even describe it.”

That sauce was the hit of the entire barbecue. People kept asking what was in it, and several guests asked me to text them the recipe. My neighbor Bob, who’s usually pretty reserved about food, actually said, “This is the best thing I’ve put on shrimp in twenty years.”

What Is Honey Old Bay Sauce?

Honey Old Bay Sauce is one of those recipes that comes together almost by accident but ends up feeling like it should have always existed. It’s made by melting butter with Old Bay seasoning, garlic, and a touch of paprika, then whisking in honey and a splash of vinegar or lemon juice. The result is a sauce that’s sticky, a little sweet, and has just the right kick from the spices. It works beautifully as a drizzle, dip, or glaze, and it only takes a few minutes to make. Once you try it, you’ll start finding excuses to use it.

Key Ingredients in This Honey Old Bay Sauce

PIN IT

• Honey – brings natural sweetness and a sticky texture

• Old Bay seasoning – the star spice blend with savory, zesty flavor

• Butter – adds richness and smooth body to the sauce

• Apple cider vinegar or lemon juice – balances the sweetness with acidity

• Hot sauce (optional) – for a little extra kick

• Garlic powder – gives a mellow savory depth

• Smoked paprika (optional) – adds a hint of smoky warmth

• Black pepper – rounds out the seasoning

Tips for Perfect Honey Old Bay Sauce at Home

• Balance sweetness and spice – Start with equal parts honey and Old Bay, then adjust to taste.

• Use unsalted butter – It helps control saltiness while giving the sauce a rich base.

• Whisk well – Ensures the honey, butter, and spices blend smoothly without separating.

• Add a squeeze of lemon juice – Brightens the sauce and balances the richness.

• Spice it up if desired – A pinch of cayenne or dash of hot sauce adds heat.

• Serve warm – The sauce thickens as it cools, so use it right after making.

• Versatile uses – Brush on seafood, toss with wings, drizzle over veggies, or use as a dip for fries.

Kitchen Equipment Needed

• Small saucepan – to melt the butter and cook the sauce

• Wooden spoon or silicone spatula – for stirring while it simmers

• Measuring cups and spoons – to portion out the honey, butter, and spices

• Whisk – to blend everything into a smooth sauce

• Heatproof jar or container – for storing leftovers in the fridge

• Small ladle or spoon – for drizzling or serving the sauce

Best Uses for Honey Old Bay Sauce

Honey Old Bay Sauce is one of those things that ends up on more than just the dish you planned it for. I first made it for shrimp, but quickly realized it works with so much more. Drizzle it over crab legs or fried fish and it feels like a seafood feast. Brush it on chicken wings or grilled drumsticks, and it turns into a sticky glaze that everyone loves. I’ve even set it out as a dip for french fries and hush puppies, and it disappeared fast. It’s quick, versatile, and has a way of stealing the spotlight.

PIN IT

Variations and Substitutions

• Citrus twist – swap apple cider vinegar with lemon or orange juice for brightness.

• Extra heat – add more hot sauce or a pinch of cayenne pepper.

• Smoky version – use smoked paprika or a drop of liquid smoke.

• Herb boost – stir in chopped parsley, chives, or dill at the end.

• Different sweetener – replace honey with maple syrup or agave nectar.

• Butter substitute – use olive oil for a lighter option.

• Spice swap – try Cajun seasoning or Creole seasoning instead of Old Bay.

How to Store Honey Old Bay Sauce

When I make a batch of Honey Old Bay Sauce, I always set some aside because it keeps really well. Once the sauce has cooled, I pour it into a clean jar or airtight container and keep it in the fridge. It stays good for about a week, and the flavors seem to blend even more as it rests. When I’m ready to use it again, I just warm it gently on the stove or in the microwave until it loosens up to that pourable, sticky texture. It’s an easy way to have a ready-to-go sauce for quick meals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it ahead of time?
Yes, it can be made a few days in advance and stored in the fridge until needed.

Can I freeze the sauce?
Freezing isn’t ideal, as the texture can change once thawed.

Is it very spicy?
Not unless you add extra hot sauce or cayenne—it’s easy to adjust the heat.

Can I use something other than honey?
Yes, maple syrup or agave nectar both work well.

What can I serve it with besides seafood?
It’s great on chicken wings, roasted vegetables, fries, or even drizzled over cornbread.

Don’t Miss More Recipes